Search This Blog

Wednesday, May 7, 2014

Lyme disease as a New World disease

Has Lyme been around thousands of years?  Maybe. The spirochete responsible for Lyme, Borrelia burgdorferi was found in a hip bone fragment from the 5300 year old iceman discovered in the permafrost in the Swiss/ Austria Alps 2 decades ago.   Illness attributed to the spirochete before the 1970s appears to have been rare; sporadic cases of a relatively mild disease were reported in Europe dating back to the 1800s.  Lyme disease and its attendant spirochete were never know in the New World until quite recently, about 40 years ago.  The epidemic, for no apparent reason, suddenly appeared in Old Lyme Connecticut the 1970s. 

Cases of a new disease were reported to The Connecticut State Department of Health in 1975. The acting director of the Preventable Diseases Division in Connecticut discussed these cases with Dr. Steere and Dr Malwesta, rheumatology section Yale University of Medicine.

Why not the CDC?

At that time the CDC had something of a storied history.  The CDC was founded in 1946 but initially was a small organization with a small staff of engineers and etymologists studying malaria in war torn areas.  Epidemiology was added in 1949. Disease surveillance became the cornerstone of the CDC’s mission. With the Korean War the focus changed to bio-warfare. The Public Health Service merged with the CDC in the late 1950s and the CDC took over the Tuskegge study which observed the effects of untreated syphilis on black males. The CDC underplays this on their website, defensively mentioning the words television and the media.  The CDC touts its successes:  polio, immunizations, small pox, Legionnaires disease, toxic shock syndrome and HIV/AIDS.  Lyme is not mentioned. 

In the mid-1970s, instead of involving the Federal Government, an acting director in public health sought the advice of Dr. Steer, a rheumatology fellow, a doctor still in training.
In the initial report 39 children and 12 adults in Old Lyme and East Haddam were reported to have what was described as mild arthritis. Cases mostly occurred in rural and wooded areas. Half the patients had only joint pain while others also complained of fever, headaches, weakness and a rash. An unusual skin lesion was reported in one quarter of the cases. The cause was unknown and thought to be a virus. 

Where did it come from?

Historically, many diseases have jumped from one continent to the next; imported by humans. Syphilis was imported the Americas along with Christopher Columbus and other conquistadors from Europe in the late 15th century with devastating consequences. The even more devastating plague of smallpox, another “gift” from the “old word” to the New World was yet to follow. 

We do not know the origins of Lyme although there is much speculation.

Local state departments and the CDC continue to deny the existence of Lyme disease in various locations.  I am now seeing a cohort of Lyme patients from central Florida. I have patients who have contracted Lyme disease in such heretofore unlikely of places such as New Mexico. 

We have a pretty good idea of how Lyme is spread from one community to the next. Migratory patterns of a wide variety of birds. This mode of transmission has been very efficient. 

Comment:  Why did the CDC suddenly increase its estimate of the number of new cases of Lyme disease annually from 30,000 to 300,000? The CDC always knew that the number 30,000, the number of reported cases was a fraction of the true number of cases  The majority of cases they count are not reported, cases associated with a rash, treated by primary care physicians. Over 2 million Lyme disease test ordered annually and this is probably and an under-estimation. How many new cases of Lyme are missed, the diagnosis tragically overlooked because the signs and symptoms of the disease were not recognized by treating physicians - or "providers."

Seventy five percent of new cases are associated with a rash according to the CDC? The CDC case definition emphasizes the presence of EM rash causing a bias in this manufactured number.  The earliest data presented here show that only 25% of patients with acute Lyme recalled a rash. This suggests that no more than 25% of patients with acute Lyme disease present with a rash – not 75%.
Unfortunately, as I hear over and over again for my patients, poorly informed physicians tell patients they cannot have Lyme disease since they never had a rash.

I sense that the CDC suffers with an identity crisis. What is its mission? Surveillance. Epidemiology. Disease prevention. Aiding doctors in the management of acute and threatening epidemics. Medical research.  Coordinating research with NIH. Working with other strategic partners. The CDC has a lot on its plate and seems to be understaffed.  What is the basis for its alliance with the Infectious Disease Society of America? Are the IDSA guidelines evidence-based? Are they peer-reviewed? The IDSA guidelines are opinion driven, steeped in politics and certainly not peer-reviewed by any outside organization.

The NIH is still busy doing research on this 40 year old, new and emerging and most controversial disease -- how can the CDC pen guidelines written in stone? How can these guidelines be used to deprive physicians of medical licenses and deprive patients of access to care? 

Sweeping generalizations have been made of the basis of limited studies with tiny numbers of patients through of the eyes of a few biased, academically linked researchers with an axe to grind. 

We do not know the true incidence of the disease. We do not know how many cases are chronic. We know even less about other tickborne coinfections. Very few physicians have ever heard of Babesia duncani, yet it appears to infect as many as one in three patients with Lyme disease -- not to mention new and emerging species of Bartonella many of which are yet named. The 40-year-olds of today are the first generation of America who suffer with more fatigue, joint pain, disability and impaired quality of life than their parents.  What truly is the scope of this hidden epidemic, swept under the rug?

And then finally one must ask the questions: who is running the mental hospital? The inmates?  Where does this leave all the patients who are yet unable to find answers and frequently greeted with hostility from the very health care providers who should be providing them sympathy and support?


Russ said...

Just a general comment to thank you for your blog posts. I find them informative and refreshing. I am a 61 yo retired systems engineer living in SE PA who has been fighting lyme for 4.5 years. Have been on oral ABX most of that time, restarting typically a month or two after relapsing. The ABX provide me with an almost normal life. I have digested most of K. Spreen's new textbook and am always searching for new info. Someday maybe we will figure this out, and it will be in large part due to people like you. Thanks much. Keep up the good fight.

Unknown said...

Very nice article! One of the best I've read in a long time! I did not know that after Columbus set sail on the ocean blue, he had brought along syphilis too! But, personally, I don't think that Lyme, per se, with its myriad of symptoms, was around 5300 years ago! I believe that spirochetes were, indeed! This is not an argument, obviously, only an opinion! I think that this business is man-made, particularily of the bio-warfare, liquid chemicals variety! I feel like I've been poisoned and like I am a walking toxic waste dump, to be quite frank! The CDC is just ridiculous! What exactly ARE they doing? They post that they are concerned about 'their app' and fB page, and they tell people to exercise to avoid weight gain and High Blood Pressure! Well, big surprise there! They are definitely hiding something! I will say, I asked a lead panelist on a World Health Day webinar back in April, who was actually associated with the CDC, what they are doing about Lyme Disease and why there is the big controversy surrounding it? Although I put my few questions in at the beginning of the presentation, she waited till the very end of it, all the while other questions WERE indeed being answered in a timely fashion, and stated, "That's a good question, Christi..." That was it! She didn't even have an opportunity to spell out my full name, Christine! I was so upset! I should have made a screen shot of that! What is their purpose, anyways!? Great question! They seem to be sleeping! I would like to end by saying thank you for giving a 'shout out' to Central Florida, which is where I live and was bit! Yes, I am fortunate to at least know that much about this mysterious disease and the controersy surrounding it! It was in Land O Lakes, FL and I have not been the same since! And I'm really not sure if I will ever feel "normal" again! I don't remember that feeling anymore!

ocean servicie said...

hello to you all, my name is Wendy Brimm , i am from Vegas here in united state, i wish to tell you all, how i find a doctor that cure me from SKIN CANCER, which i had for three years with his natural herbal medicine he gave to me , it all went this way, i was internet that very day when i saw a comment of a woman called MARIA KATRINA from united kingdom sharing her testimony about how this very doctor cured her of HIV, and he also cured AIDS too, but i never really believed but i just decided to give it a try and i contacted DOCTOR HAKIM, so he told me everything i needed to know and what to do to get cured and free from my cancer issue, so i went straight and make provisions for the herbs which he used to prepare medicine for me,i applied the medicine and just to see that the exact day which doctor harkim said i we be cured i was felling good and healthy at once, my strength was regained i went for check up in the hospital and my family doctor told me i am free from cancer my skin can back to normal, this was the greatest miracle that has happened to me in my life, and i promise doctor hakim that i we share his good work to the world, these are few i can say about this DOCTOR HAKIM, i went with my family to thank him for his great work and solution in my life, wish i never expected this was possible, I we like you to contact him if you have any health issue i believe this doctor can help you out as well.

Requisite Software said...

Just something to point out. The 1970s is about the time climate change became noticeable in Mauna Loa, Hawaii. I don't know if that would have anything to do with increased virulence of the disease in North America.

From what I under the Borrelia bacteria originated in Eastern Europe so the range for infection shouldn't have really expanded with a change in climate. I believe climate in Eastern Europe to be similar to that of the eastern US.

Unknown said...

Diagnosed with Lyme and treated for only ten days of Doxy during the beginning of this past summer. I just turned 30. I've been having symptoms for years and never remember a tick bite. I'm also in Florida. My current doctor was actually the one who suggested screening me for Lyme Disease when I talked about my joint pain. She also tested my ANA, the Rheumatoid Factor, and my SED rate. Everything was fine except that both ELISA EIA numbers were around 1.5 (their "normal range" was between 0 and .9), yet there were absolutely NO IgG antibodies present, and the only two IgM antibodies present were 23 and 41. I've been trying to figure out how to interpret these results - as my doctor simply had me take the 10 days of antibiotics and she hasn't spoken to me about it since, except to say "Oh, we cleared that all up." That would be fine and dandy if I didn't still have mental fog, a dry cough, horrible pain in my joints, headaches, chest pain, fatigue, etc... Thank you for writing this blog, though. It's brought me a bit of insight.

Unknown said...

Have you read the book Lab 257?

Jessica Morgan said...

Am Jessica Morgan,i have read testimonies about this great man called Dr.Ekpiku how he helped people to get pregnant and also help people to cure Herpes simplex virus with his herbal medicine, so i decided to give him a try, i am here today to give my own testimony on how this great man helped me to cure my Herpes disease and also helped my sister to get pregnant, i just told him and he said he was going to work on it miraculously and in a short period of time i was lifted from these terrible disease. And it took my sister just a week to get pregnant after he was done. Contact this great man and He will help you no matter the problem you are facing. Email him at or call +2348073673757 OR whatsapp him.THESE ARE THE THINGS Dr. Ekpiku. . HERPES . HIV/AIDS . CANCER