Monday, September 11, 2017

Debugging the bug





Lyme disease is caused by Borrelia burgdorferi and other related species of Borrelia.  “Lyme disease” was coined by Steere in 1977.  Microbiologist Willie Burgdorfer discovered the germ in 1981 -- A thin, elongated spiral shaped bacteria, or spirochete residing in the gut of ticks. 
These bacteria are persistent and frequently cause chronic disease.   The belief that the bacteria persist has been refuted by the IDSA for decades.  The IDSA is wrong.  The narrative oft repeated describing the structure and function of the spirochete by those in my camp, is outdated and incorrect.  
This post is an effort to correct the record. 
The following statements are wrong and I explain why. 
#1 Lyme bacteria have 3 forms:  spirochete, L-form and cyst form. 
Lyme does not exist in an L-form.  An L form is a cell wall deficient bacterium derived from a bacterium that ordinarily has a cell wall.   Lyme lacks a cell wall to begin with so this is an impossibility. Lyme bacteria possess a double outer membrane and no cell wall.  Bacterial cysts do no occur. This is a feature of protozoa. Lyme bacteria are pleomorphic with “phenotypic” variation.  These chameleons of the bacterial world frequently present as a round bodied forms which are treatment resistant.  In summary: No L-forms, No true cysts. Yes, spirochetes have shape shifting ability – pleomorphic variation, commonly observed as round body forms, blebs and many others.  
#2 Lyme bacteria persist in large measure because they hide in cells (are intracellular).
Lyme bacteria primarily exist outside host cells (extracellular).  Intracellular forms exist but are relatively uncommon. The bacteria adhere to a protein matrix between cells.  Primary mechanisms of persistence are biofilm formation and pleomorphic variability.  The spirochetes are anaerobic (do not require oxygen) and therefore are able to live in tissues with a poor blood/oxygen supply, e.g. joint cartilage. These bacteria easily cross the blood brain barrier which is a safe-haven because immune responses are limited. The bacteria may survive in other “immune privileged” areas. Intracellular localization is a relatively minor means of immune evasion. 
#3 Treatment must include: cell wall drugs (beta-lactams), intracellular drugs and “cyst busters.”  
Assuming we are talking about the bacterial cells (not host) With Lyme spirochetes all antibiotics inhibit or kill Lyme work via an intracellular mechanism.   The molecules that form the bacterial cell wall are called peptidoglycans.  Borrelia spirochetes possess strands of peptidoglycans internally, acting as an internal skeleton.  When beta-lactams kill Lyme, the action is inside the cells. The other classes of antibiotics generally work inside the cells, disrupting DNA/RNA, metabolic pathways or protein synthesis.  If we are instead referring to drugs which penetrate host cells, antibiotics from many classes may penetrate host cells, including beta-lactams. 
4#  Flagyl is a cyst buster.  

If one is referred to round forms of Lyme, Flagyl is no more effective (in a test tube) than doxycycline.  Empiric evidence and clinical practice inform us that Flagyl is very effective and may be synergistic with other drugs. 
In summary:  No L forms.  No cyst forms.  No cyst busters.  Ceftin, amoxicillin, others function as intracellular antibiotics when used against Lyme. 
Lyme spirochetes have a developed ability to persist in the face of adversity.  This phenomenon is not unknown in the world of bacteriology. For example, tuberculosis.  TB is treated with a 4-drug combination for 2 months and a 2-drug combination for another 2 months.  This complicated formula is the results of decades of research.  
Lyme (chronic) has not had this sort of attention from the medical community which maintains the persistent delusion the disease does not exist.  

Friday, August 4, 2017

Autoimmune encephalitis and Lyme


Many patients suffering with Lyme disease also suffer with autoimmune encephalitis. Perhaps this is widely understood. A better understanding of the phenomena may be diagnostically and clinically important. 
The terms Lyme encephalopathy, Lyme encephalitis and neuroborreliosis have been used interchangeably.  Typical symptoms include “brain fog,” memory issues, poor focus and concentration, confusion, disorientation and other forms of cognitive dysfunction or impairment. 

Lyme patients with predominant autoimmune issues have strange experiences which they may find difficult to put into words.  Complaints I hear, include:  strange head pressure (not headache); “brain on fire,” derealization (feel like on a different planet); sensory overload, brain shuts down; altered visual perceptions; hallucinogenic-like perceptions, experience; severe, strange depression, treatment resistant and many others. These patients may experience a unique world of misery which is otherwise inexplicable and indescribable.  

SPECT and PET brain scans are usually abnormal. 

Lab tests may help.  Anti-GAD-65 antibodies are frequently present.  Anti-dopamine receptor antibodies may be present, currently I get this information through the Cunningham Panel (Moleculera), other labs may offer a less expensive test.  There are a dozen or so known autoantibodies known in patients with autoimmune encephalitis but commercial tests are not available.  Anti NMDA receptor antibodies may be checked but I have not seen a positive in Lyme patients. 

With antibiotic therapy there may be a dramatic response: they get much worse.  This is even more the case with therapy directed at Babesia and Bartonella. One recent patient tolerates Rocephin but shuts down (becomes miserable) with the smallest doses of Mepron, Bactrim, Rifampin and Flagyl/Tindamax. 
This is not a Herxheimer reaction.  This is the most crucial point of this post.  Continued therapy will not lead to improvement.  A Herxheimer reaction is caused by a mini-cytokine-storm.  It is normal, although exaggerated response to killing germs. This other reaction is caused by exacerbation of an autoimmune response: the production of self-directed antibodies. This is very troublesome and difficult to manage.  

Treatments may include:  IVIG, Plasmapheresis, immunosuppressant drugs and steroids.  Make sure you get the diagnosis right.  

A short trial of high-dose steroids may be therapeutic and diagnostic.  IVIG, dosed 1.5-2 gm/kg may the most practical therapy for the greatest number of patients.  Getting insurance coverage is the main barrier. The primary immunosuppressive therapy is Rituximab.

Antibiotics are required as a mainstay of therapy once the autoimmune process is controlled. 
One patient is fairly well managed with IVIG, antibiotics and Rituximab.  The dogma that Lyme patients should never receive steroids or immunosuppressive agents is not always true.  

Tertiary care specialists will need to be enlisted in many cases.  The disease is very complex and multifaceted.   Something to keep in mind when patients do not respond to standard therapy as expected. 

Monday, May 22, 2017

Lyme Primer


There is no good, concise primer on Lyme disease, from my perspective. I haven’t written one. My patients come are confused and bewildered. Not surprising. There is a wealth of (difficult to follow and contradicting) information and views on the internet – and elsewhere. When colleagues and I communicate so “clearly” to our patients, we likely fail to see the glassy eyed moment at which the patient, who 1) is not a doctor and 2) has brain fog from Lyme has been irreparably lost.  On the other hand, much info written by lay folks is overly simplified and simply wrong. 
Here is an effort to outline some of the key points. 
Yes, Lyme is controversial, AND political.  Why? The answer is complex, hopefully covered in one or more of my blog posts.  I reader must understand the why for any of this to make any real sense. 
On the one hand, (standard view, shared by CDC, IDSA, medical specialists and 99.9% of practicing doctors in the US), Lyme is relatively straightforward.  Tick bite. Rash – bull’s eye. Various syndromes possible, such as Bell’s Palsy, swollen knee, meningitis, heart block (heart may stop) and a few others. Treatment is simple. Either doxycycline (amoxicillin if allergic) or IV Rocephin is given for a set number of days, i.e. 21 days, the germs are killed and the patient gets better. End of story. By the way – the typical blood test is highly accurate and dependable, if not in early disease, certainly in later forms of illness. And, chronic Lyme disease does not exist. 
On the other hand; its complicated. Chronic disease is the rule. Most patients do not recall a tick bite or a rash. Even when early disease is found, for example with a classic rash, 20% of patients may not get better with “standard” therapy. Coinfections are common. (the 99.9% group does not believe in coinfections). Lyme is caused by a type of microbe or microorganism called a bacterium. Bacteria may assume various shapes, forms and function. Most bacteria are harmless or good, including those that live in our gut. The Lyme bacteria has an elongated spiral, cork-screw shape referred to as a spirochete. Most bacteria have round and rod shapes. Lyme is amongst an elite group of bacteria which are pathogenic, those that call human disease or illness. Lyme can sometimes make us incredibly sick and even kill. At other times, it behaves as an innocent parasite, living of the wealth of the land (or bodies).  Lyme (Borrelia burdorferi, scientifically – pop quiz on Friday) is a zoonosis. That means it normally resides in animals and may be transmitted to humans. Lovely.  The main home for these curled up bacteria is mice. They trek from mice (reservoir we call it), to human via an intermediary (called a vector), in this case, as you probably know, from tiny ticks which may be impossible to see.  
We think coinfections are the rule, not the exception. No. Coinfections are not another form of Lyme, as I oft hear. They are distinct pathogenic microbes which are carried via the same route, mouse – tick – us.  The most prominent coinfections are: Bartonella, another bacterium, rod shaped this time, and Babesia, a more complex microbe, a protozoan, malaria-like which lives inside red blood cells. If this is too complicated, just remember that two other germs frequently accompany Lyme and may us sick, or very sick. 
Blood tests are very confusing.  Patients mistakenly think that bands are strains of ore species of Lyme or coinfections, etc. Most stuff on the internet which tries to simplify concepts of testing has it wrong one way or another. You can read blog posts and try to understand testing. All you really need to know is that testing, as with ticks, sucks. Not accurate. Not dependable. Tests are still done and may be very helpful. Only a doctor can make sense of the results and “read the tea leaves” in many cases.  Here I am not referring to the 99.9% of doctors mentioned above.  Please don’t spend thousands of dollars without a doctor’s guidance. Or triumphantly show up at a doctor’s office with a piece of paper in hand from an expensive lab. Not to be condescending, but let us sort out such complicated things. 
If blood tests aren’t reliable, how the heck are you going to diagnose the illness? You might ask. 
OK. A lot of Lyme patients come in with a bunch of nonspecific and confusing symptoms. Absolutely. Here is what I say. First go to all the regular doctors. Have the regular tests done. See the regular specialists. Let me forewarn: If your doctor(s) says you need a shrink because its psychosomatic, that you have fibromyalgia or chronic fatigue syndrome, and you know your doctor(s) is wrong, you are probably right, something else is going on. In the words of the fictional Sherlock Holmes (roughly): when you have ruled out the impossible, then whatever remains, no matter how unlikely, must be the truth. OK. I never got it either. Anyway, perhaps you should consider Lyme. I think Lyme is common and therefore likely, they (the 99.9%) think otherwise. 

Lyme effects the brain and causes neuropsychiatric symptoms. This is important. Diagnoses such as dementia and mental illness may be wrong. Very wrong. 
You should certainly suspect Lyme if you spend time hiking, camping gardening, taking kids to parks, going to picnics and sitting on the grass, especially walking through tall grass or romping in piles of fall leaves, have dogs or other pets, AND, if you live in most places in North America (OK – probably all of us).  We are all at risk.  Some of my patients live in the city and deny any of the above risk factors. 
What are the symptoms of Lyme? Anything. Am I kidding – not much.  On the internet check lists of symptoms include anything you can think of.  Let me pare it down. 
Think Lyme, Babesia and Bartonella. Three germs. There is a triad of symptoms which seem to be remarkably linked to each one, with surprising consistency.
LYME: FATIGUE (which poor sleep etc.), PAIN (migratory, hurts here one day and somewhere else the next, usually joints like knees and hands), BRAIN DYSFUNCTION (changes in cognition, can’t remember names or words, getting lost or confused, not functional well, etc.
BABESIA: NIGHT SWEATS (may feel flulike with low grade fevers, others), AIR HUNGER (Strangely, feels like you can’t get enough air), MOOD CHANGES (Depressed, oddly cry for no apparent reason, others).
BARTONELLA: TENDON PAIN (Pain more likely in places like heels, shins, neck +/- headache), MOOD CHANGES (Irritability, anxiety, anger, rage, crazy) and RASHES (Not as common, several types, stretch marks especially). 
Three germs, each with 3 symptoms.  All overlap like a complicated Venn diagram.
Lyme and friends (co-pathogens) can cause any other, fill in the blank, symptom as well. But if some combination of the above symptoms is not present think of something else first. 
Yes. Lyme is the great imitator. It can look like and cause many other illnesses such as MS and rheumatoid arthritis. 
If I didn’t mention it, testing for coinfections is also very difficult.
Treatment. Easy for the 99.9%. Hard for the rest of us. Expect multiple antibiotics and other agents given over a prolonged period, if you are suffering with chronic forms of the disease. There are different theories regarding the details of treatment. There is no correct approach. What works for one person may not work for someone else. 
Cure? Hard to say. Patients certainly get into remission. 
Why so hard to get rid of?  It’s complicated. Suffice it to say that experiments in mice, dogs and primates --- and in test tubes, show that Lyme bacteria persist, despite our best efforts to eradicate them. 
Many (most) patients seen in a Lyme clinic have previously seen many, many physicians who have frequently told the patient: we don’t know what is wrong but we are absolutely, 100% certain it is not Lyme disease!  Keep in mind these doctors, especially ones at academic centers, the cream of the crop, the Harvards and Hopkins of the world are part of the 99.9% of doctors who are sure that everything written here beyond the “On the one hand” paragraph above believe everything else written here is absolute hogwash. 
On the flip side, some think everything is Lyme disease. It may be dangerously over-diagnosed.  I have seen cancer misdiagnosed as Lyme disease. As I said above. Get everything else checked out first. 
Why are the experts so certain and in my opinion frequently so wrong?  Learn the politics. Read my blog posts.  See “Under Our Skin.” Read “Cure Unknown.” You must understand why the entire medical field (so call mainstream medical community) soundly rejects the idea that Lyme is behind so much chronic disease. Don’t look any further until this makes some sense. 
I always say: Lyme is the most controversial disease in the history of medicine. Well, at least since they stopped poking holes through people’s skulls suffering with madness to let out the evil spirits.

Monday, April 3, 2017

The whole world is on disability

Disabled, or just desperate? Rural Americans turn to disability as jobs dry up

Recent article Washington Post

Its rural America. The whole word is on disability.  The number of Americans surviving on government disability checks has surged to 17 million and the number keeps growing.   Pain clinics are overflowing.  The 39 year old man, pictured above, has recurring painful, swollen fingers and recurrent knee pain.  Is it really due to past use of a hammer and a distant fall ?

Baby boomers, middle aged, retired or pushing retirement age, are the first generation of American who feel worse than their parents did at the same age.  32% of their parents reported excellent health and only 13% of (my group) boomers claims the same.  My cohorts have more aches and pains and are two times more like to need a walker or other assistive device compared with their parents.

Boomer parents smoked and loaded up on butter and cholesterol with impunity. They didn't go to gyms or run. They still had a better quality of life.

There is an exception: Hawaii, the one state with no reported native cases of Lyme disease.

Boomer parents didn't have fibromyalgia or chronic fatigue syndrome.  Boomer  parents walked in the woods without a second thought.

Baby boomers had no idea the woods weren't safe. They had no idea that newly arrived, tiny, nearly invisible ticks could make them deathly ill.  They were into exercise, hiking, camping; the great outdoors.

The CDC admits there are 300,000 new cases of Lyme annually. This a low ball estimate: most cased go unrecognized. People are getting sicker, and in so many unexpected ways. How do you tie the epidemic of MS with arthritic joints (if you are mainstream)?

Primary care clinics are deluged with a new class of patients. An onslaught of chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia and psychiatric illness -- especially somatization disease. There is an epidemic of craziness. Doctors frequently cringe when certain names appear on their daily schedule. Published data state somatization disorders is found in a small (stats vary, not clear)  but increasing percentage of the general population. Somehow these dreaded patients are filling the rosters of doctor's appointment schedules. Its like a zombie apocalypse.

What of the patients. The miserable souls get stuffed with pills that just make them feel even worse. Cymbalta and Lyrica. The patients are bounced around to numerous specialist and subspecialist, all anxious to scoot them out their offices as quickly as possible. Do not pass go, do not collect 200 dollars. Finally the patients turn to OxyContin which takes the edge off their misery. Many of the miserable sit on the porches of their dilapidated houses, nursing one too many beers, washing down an Oxy or two.

The whole word is on disability.

Readers, you can make a change. Contact your local politicians, state delegates, etc. Tell them to stop the witch hunts and persecution of the few doctors who challenge the status quo.

Its like medical marijuana, which helps some Lyme patients. The system tried to stop it. The FDA and DEA are still furious.  Ultimately, public outcry was strong enough to find a path around the system.

Access to Lyme doctors should be a fundamental right, a civil right, a patient choice issue.


The CDC states that 54 million adults suffer with some form of arthritis, a leading cause of disability.

Fast Facts -- (CDC published material)

  • In the United States, 23% of all adults—over 54 million people—have arthritis.
  • By 2040, an estimated 26% of all adults—over 78 million people—will have arthritis.
  • Arthritis is more common among women (24%) than men (18%), and it affects all racial and ethnic groups.
  • Arthritis commonly occurs with other chronic diseases, like diabetes, heart disease, and obesity, and can make it harder for people to manage these conditions.

RESEARCH LETTER --- 2013 - Dr.Dana King, West VA.
ONLINE FIRST The Status of Baby Boomers’ Health in the United States: The Healthiest Generation?
From 1946 through 1964, 78 million children (“baby boomers”) were born in the United States. In 2010, baby boomers made up 26.1% of the word population.1 Medicine has improved significantly during baby boomers’ lifetimes. Although these advantages have led to a progressively increasing life expectancy, 2 previous studies have shown mixed results regarding whether baby boomers are healthier than prior generations.3,4 The present study examined the health status of aging baby boomers relative to the previous generation to provide a vitally important context for health workforce and policy planning in the coming years.
Methods. National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), including NHANESIII(1988-1994) (for previous generation) and the NHANES for 2007 to 2010 (for baby boomers), focusing on respondents  46 to 64y years during either period... Results. The demographic characteristics of the cohorts were very similar except for the proportions in each racial/ ethnic group, with greater proportions of non-Hispanic blacks(11.3%vs9.4%)and Hispanics (9.8%vs3.7%) in the 2007-2010 group compared with the1988-1994 group (P .001). The mean (SD) ages were 54.1 (0.03) years in the 2007-2010 group and 54.5(0.03) years in the1988 1994 group; there was no difference in sex between the 2 cohorts (49.1%male [2007-2010 group] vs 47.5% male [1988-1994 group]).
Overall health status was lower in baby boomers, with 13.2% reporting “excellent” health compared with 32% of individuals in the previous generation (P .001). Of the sampled baby boomers, compared with the previous generation, 6.9% vs 3.3% used a walking assist device (P .001)

Thursday, March 30, 2017

Lyme and Fake News


I have known this 54-year-old woman for more than 2 years.  When she presented to my office she was a mess.  She thought she had Lyme disease after watching the movie “The Punk Singer.” She was disabled at the time, having been diagnosed with fibromyalgia, by her rheumatologist and diagnosed with depression and ADHD by her psychiatrist. She was told she did not have Lyme disease because a test was negative. I have previously discussed a gazillion reasons Lyme tests are unreliable. The persisting ignorance of other physicians, despite laws passed in VA and MD that require doctors inform patients the test is not reliable, is untenable.  My patient essentially lives in the woods, her back yard abuts a large park and she typically sees 20 deer daily in her back yard daily.  She is disabled by an illness, which is certainly not fibromyalgia and had to sell her business.  Her profession was:  boarding and walking dogs. Her son suffers with a similar disorder and 5 dogs she cared for tested positive for Lyme disease.   A reader might wonder: “how can the doctors discount Lyme when the history is so compelling?”  The answer is simple: Her doctors will not, cannot consider such a thing, when it is firmly entrenched in their brain(s)/medical world view that the diagnosis does not exist. For these doctors, Lyme is "Fake News".
Welcome to my world of medicine. The world is flat, not round.
My colleagues have been indoctrinated to believe: Lyme is rare, easy to diagnose and easy to cure. In my version of reality Lyme can devastate, maim and kill; lab tests are inaccurate, especially the commonly used one; treatment can be very difficult and prolonged.
The majority opinion still rules the land.  Opinion is the operative word.  As is said, you are entitled to your own opinion, not your own facts.  These blogs, scientific literature, books and films  and thousands of patient's stories, clearly tell us that Lyme is real.  It is the other side that has been beguiled by Fake News.
When I met this patient, she was bedridden. She had gained 60 pounds. Thinking about getting out of bed was a chore. Showers were virtually impossible. She was frequently confused and found her memory was slipping away. Her previous eidetic (photographic) memory was gone. Conversing was a challenge. Words didn’t come out right.  She couldn’t fall asleep, and on the occasion she did, she woke up every 2-3 hours. Her entire body hurt, head to toe. She was very weak. She couldn't hold a cup of coffee. Even cutlery dropped from her hands.   Her body felt numb and odd electrical sensations frightened her, sharp and burning, and without warning in differing areas of her body.  Numerous other symptoms included: fevers, chills, night sweats, hearing loss, loss of vision, floaters, neck pain, severe air hunger, new GERD, frequent urination, joint pain and swelling, stiffness, headaches, disorientation, inability to read and write, depression, mood swings, easy tearing and recurrent generalized itchy rashes.
There is more to her story.
As a child she had recurring sinusitis, bronchitis and pneumonia. She was diagnosed with asthma and spent a lot of time in an “iron lung.”
She experiences a lot of hives and itching which seem to appear randomly. She described a condition called dermatographia, written words on her skin become red and persist for a long time.
Lab tests:  Tickborne infection panel: negative Lyme, positive Bartonella, all others negative.  Histamine and tryptase normal.  Celiac panel: deaminated gliadin IgA aby 7 (positive cut off 19).  Imunnoglobulins: IgG 792 (normal 700-1600), IgG subclasses 1 and 3 mildly low, Pneumoccocal 14 aby 9 strains not immune.
I diagnosed her with: Lyme disease, babesiosis, bartonellosis, gluten sensitivity, immune deficiency (CVID), chronic variable immunodeficiency syndrome.
She tested positive for Bartonella; on clinical grounds, Babesia was the big issue.
I diagnosed a form of mast cell activation disorder based on the history. Blood tests and urine tests are usually negative and the diagnosis is made clinically.
CVID was diagnosed by: history of chronic infection; low immunoglobulin level; poor immunity to Strep pneumonia strains (which didn’t change post Pneumovax, pneumonia vaccine).
Gluten sensitivity was a guess.  A gliadin IgA antibody greater than 3-4 makes me suspicious.  The celiac panel reports 4 values: Gliadin IgA, gliadin IgG, tTG IgA, tTG IgG. Most doctors only look at the tTG IgA.
Treatment:  Diet -- low histamine and no gluten. Mast cell stabilization agents. Antibiotics. Anti-malarials. IVIG.  
Discussion
I don’t automatically tell patients to eliminate gluten. Most my patients tolerate it. A slight bump in any of the antibody levels seems to correlate with gluten intolerance.
Most patients do not have significant mast cell issues.  In this case, a typical history was given.
 Most patients do not have an immune deficiency issue provable based on current standards.  Patients with chronic Lyme all have dysfunctional immunity.  In this case the diagnosis was firmly based on lab tests and a lack of immune response to vaccine.  Generally getting IVIG covered is tough and otherwise cost prohibitive.
I always include treatment for Lyme at the start, rather than targeting only a coinfection such as Babesia.  Lyme forms persisters but does not gain resistance to antibiotics in the usual way. In other words, the same drugs will always work. I typically work up to cocktail of 3 drugs when starting an oral regimen, adding one at a time. With intravenous therapy, I use fewer antibiotics.  Many antibiotics interact with Mepron, decreasing efficacy of the latter.
Mepron is still first line therapy: I always start with 2 tsp twice daily, double the usual dose. If I am concerned about drug interactions I may start with artemisinin instead.  When prescribed properly, pulsed for 3 days each week, artemisinin can be very effective.  Herxheimer reactions often direct therapy based on patient tolerance.
Excessive mast cell activation is modulated with a mix of meds.  H1 and H2 histamine receptors are blocked with drugs like Xyzal and Pepcid. Leukotriens are blocked with drugs like Singulair.  Mast cells are inhibited with drugs like cromolyn, benzodiazepines and ketotifen. Diet is key.
IVIG is given either subcutaneously or intravenously.  For immune disorders a lower dose is approved, 0.6 gm/kg.  With neurological disorders a higher dose, typically 1 gm/kg is used.  For autoimmune neurological disorders such as PANS, a higher dose of 1.5 gm/kg is used.  These are typical starting does and may be adjusted. Usually treatment is given every 3-4 weeks.  Treatment may be long-term or indefinite.
She has done great. Improvement occurred right away with mast cell therapy and then IVIG.  Antimicrobials did their job over a period of months. Within a year, she was essentially in remission.  She had a minor relapse after stopping antibiotics, and this has cleared.
She has only one remaining symptoms.  The eidetic memory did not return. Now she only has a very good memory. 

The story, save a few details changed intentionally, accurately depicts the case.



New patients are welcomed here. 

Monday, February 27, 2017

Bicillin LA


 My patient today is a 53-year-old woman who I have known for several years.  She has been disabled with Lyme and tickborne disease for the last decade and a half.  When she came to my office a few years ago, things had taken a turn for the worse. When she came to my office for the first time she had a clear agenda. She wanted IV antibiotics, the only thing that works she said.
Her saga dates back to 1995, in Silver Spring, Maryland.  She remembers finding a tiny tick attached to her abdominal wall. She recalls that 2 weeks later a large circular rash appeared on her abdominal wall.  She recalls being barraged with symptoms soon thereafter. She experienced fevers and had trouble walking and talking. Her doctor at the time ordered an array of tests, which were negative and the physician offered no diagnosis or treatment.  An ID doctor offered nothing. A neurologist ruled out MS. Other doctors suggested her symptoms were psychosomatic and she was left to suffer, without answers or help.  

After a few years, she developed burning sensations, tremors, leg pain, weakness, muscle twitching and jerking and progressive joint pain. She developed migratory pains in her shoulders, knees, wrists, ankles, fingers and toes.  Brain symptoms were insidious.  Her thinking felt clouded. She starting getting lost. She experienced disoriented episodic confusion.  Other strange neurological symptoms seemed to mimic strokes or seizures she thought.

Finally, in 1998, she diagnosed herself.  She convinced an ID doctor to treat her.  With 6 weeks of IV antibiotics and she began to improve.  They were taken away and she crashed.  She garnered a glimmer of hope.  She began looking for help elsewhere and saw many doctors.  She ultimately found a New Jersey physician who aggressively treated her with IV antibiotics for 12 months.  She regained a quality of life, did OK for a while – a couple of years. Gradually symptoms reappeared.  She called the same doctor only to discover she was no longer in business, courtesy of the State Medical Board.
She found other doctors who were loath to prescribe IVs. Lot of doctors, lots of oral meds.  Her stomach was a mess and she was no better.  She recalls that she tested positive for Lyme, Babesia and RMSF.  She remembered a yellow paint-like medicine which made her sick and no better.

When we first met, she was desperate for help.  Mostly bedridden, getting out of bed and getting dressed was a heroic action.

A partial list of symptoms included:  exhaustion, fevers, chills, night sweats, insomnia, double vision, flashing lights, blurred vision, tinnitus, trouble speaking, trouble swallowing, swollen lymph nodes, rapid and irregular heartbeats, abdominal and pelvic pain, generalized muscle and joint pain (severe), back pain, stiffness, headache, migraine, vertigo, numbness and tingling, weakness, loss of balance, trouble walking with falls, brain fog, forgetfulness, confusion, disorientation, depression, anxiety and panic attacks.

She knew what she wanted: IV antibiotics. I wasn’t a hard sell.

Laboratory testing was positive for Bartonella antibodies.  A Lyme Western Blot at LabCorp was negative across the board.  A Stony Brook Western Blot revealed a single nonspecific IgG band (64) and 9 IgM bands: 18,25,28,31,37,41,58,64,93.
I found other abnormal laboratory values from the start.  She had a very low B12 level. A parietal cell antibody test was positive. Folic acid and vitamin D were also very low.

IV therapy didn’t work.  First there was a DVT and we had to pull the line. We tried therapy through a peripheral line and she had an adverse reaction to Rocephin. 
She became discouraged and fell off the radar.

Doing poorly, after some months, she came back to try something else:  intramuscular penicillin.  This has worked beautifully – as well as Rocephin worked, she states. All major symptoms are melting away and after a couple of months she is functioning quite well.  I give her the shots. We warm up the syringe to room temperature, and slowly inject, (deep IM, lateral aspect of iliac crest)– based on tolerance. The injection site is “rubbed in.”  She tells me the pain is relatively minor and doable, especially once weekly.

Bicillin LA is used.  It is a depot form of the drug and stays in the tissues for 2-4 weeks. I understand some patients are injecting 1.2 million units 2-3X per week.  I have found that 2.4 million units weekly works fine.  The larger volume of the higher dose is tolerated when injected slowly.

She is also treated with complementary oral drugs for Lyme and Babesia. We have found effective options which she tolerates.  She receives various supportive therapies.  And B12 injections are key.

I don’t know why the pernicious anemia (PA) diagnosis had been missed.  B12 deficiency can mimic many Lyme symptoms and B12 levels should routinely be checked.  PA is an autoimmune disorder. Autoimmune issues are prevalent amongst Lyme patients, for example, thyroid disorders. I can’t say I routinely see cases of PA, but I think the prevalence in my patient population is greater than the general population which is around 0.1%.
Bicillin LA is very expensive and insurance doesn’t cover it.  I checked on goodrx.com.  A 10 pack goes for 2,700 dollars. The monthly out of packet cost is about 1,000 dollars which isn’t horrible for a Lyme treatment.  A brief google search finds several outfits advertising a fraction of the cost.

The history that 12 months of IV Rocephin in the past imparted temporary relief would seem to augur poorly for the future. But I optimistic that a better understanding of cocktail therapy and coinfection therapy is changing this trajectory.  

An aside – let me digress.
Like many of the sickest, her positive Western Blots show a predominance of IgM responses.  In his research, Dr. Aucott incidentally discovered that about 20-25% of the populace, genetically, appears to be incapable of mounting an IgG response and may show only a weak IgM response.  This finding was predictive of a poor long term disease.  ID doctors still call IgM only “false positive” backed by the IDSA/CDC emphatically insisting that all chronic Lyme patients have the touted 5/10 IgG responses.

“You are entitled to your own opinion, but not your own facts.”  The erroneous version of reality stems from peer reviewed literature. Of course, it does.  Virtually all academic peer reviewed studies use the 5/10 IgG criteria for acceptance into clinical studies.  The conclusion that all chronic Lyme patients have these findings is silly. These criteria are used for study inclusion only. There is no clear academic peer reviewed literature that supports the notion that the criteria can be reliably used for diagnosis. Opinion papers, not research papers make this claim frequently, by incorrectly citing literature that uses the study inclusion criteria.  The first of 4 off cited academic, NIH sponsored studies (Krupp), specifically states that he included seronegative patients in his study.
The incorrect syllogistic reasoning used by the experts goes something like this:  In Lyme studies all chronic Lyme patients have CDC criteria:  patients have chronic Lyme; therefore, all chronic Lyme patients must have positive CDC findings.  And “experts” say it’s true – by fiat.

My 16-year-old daughter sees the erroneous logic and conclusion in about 30 seconds.
Everything about this case is all too familiar and horrible. Thankfully, this survivor of an odyssey of insanity and cruelty is headed for happier times.

Friday, February 17, 2017

Bartonella Madness and PANS



There exists a pernicious conspiracy between Borrelia species and Bartonella species with the intention of making us humans mad.  (This as close as I will get to conspiracy theories and politics in this BLOG).


One young man may have PANS as well (pediatric autoimmune neurological syndrome).  The teenager in question developed OCD, correctible anorexia with rapid weight loss and an aversion to one family member, for no apparent reason. The patient has no explanation or insight into this unusual change in his personality.  He is somewhat irritable, angry and rageful with other family members but not out of control, and, he does reasonably well at school, interacting well with teachers and peers.
The diagnosis of PANDAS was made because a particular expert who blames Strep.  Evidence for Strep is scant. The ASO titer and anti-DNase B were minimally elevated (Strep antibodies).  Lyme antibodies and Bartonella antibodies are present. Everyone in the family has tickborne disease.
The Cunningham panel was essentially normal.  This test is frequently relied upon for the diagnosis of PANS/PANDAS.  I ordered a GAD 65 auto-antibody which was elevated. This is a nonspecific marker but it can be associated with autoimmune encephalopathy.  
The hallmark of PANDAS is that symptoms seem to come on overnight.  In other patients, this has been the case and I have characteristically seen tics, including Tourette’s and more typical OCD manifestations. In my experience, the Cunningham panel is reliably positive.  This   patient’s symptoms came on over a short period of time, but not overnight.  The Cunningham panel is comprised a group autoantibodies directed against the brain that can be measured in a peripheral blood test. The test is supported by peer reviewed literature.
In this patient, the SPECT scan was dramatically abnormal.  This tends to confirm the diagnosis of encephalopathy but does not impute a cause.  
The patient was treated with a single dose of IVig and there was no response. The treating physician recommended waiting 6 months before retreating.  (Not what I would do).
Encephalopathy in patients with Lyme/Bartonella may be multifactorial. There may be an inflammatory component as well as an autoimmune component.  And there may be something else, far less understood.
Mysteriously, brain infectious, may induce specific effects. For example, Bartonella reliably causes, anxiety, irritability, rage (Lyme rage) in many patients. Patients may also suffer with virtually every other conceivable psychiatric symptom.
One can explain this case without consideration of PANS, or any autoimmune encephalopathy. But there is the GAD antibody, suggesting something autoimmune is going on.
Dreaded steroids (overly maligned in my opinion) are very helpful in these cases. Steroids may be administered on a one-time basis. A response to a burst of steroids is predictive of response to IVig.
If neuropsychiatric symptoms do not budge with steroids, IVig will likely fail. Steroids did not help the patient in question. This is important. IVig is prohibitively expensive. And even though tertiary academic centers recommend its use, insurance companies will not cover the therapy for PANDAS/PANS. 
If there is a dramatic response to steroids IVig can be life saver. In my experience, IVig, like antibiotics, must be given on a regular, consistent basis over a long period of time. And PANS requires high doses, 1.5 – 2 gm/kg. I have a patient who developed acute symptoms in early childhood with no evidence of strep and with 10/10 IgG Lyme WB bands and with a positive Cunningham test, who is maintained, a decade later, on IVig every 4 weeks. She has done beautifully. When IVig was withdrawn a few years ago, OCD symptoms emerged immediately.
If Bartonella is suspected to be the major culprit, specific therapy is indicated.  Combinations such as Biaxin, Rifampin and doxycycline have been used by some. This is not my favored approach. Biaxin crosses the blood brain barrier poorly (brain the target).  I like Doxycycline and Rifampin, both pass the BBB well and are active against Bartonella species. I like to add a third drug in the sulfa class. These drugs are active against Bartonella species and cross the BBB well, especially at higher doses.
This approach is not always highly effective.
The addition of low pressure hyperbaric oxygen therapy, good for all encephalopathies, may be a great adjunct.
If this isn’t working, I will go with IV therapy, preferably gentamycin and others. In lieu of IV, I have had good luck giving gentamycin as a once daily intramuscular shot. Never alone.
I stay away from quinolones which are riskier and less effective in my experience.
Gentamycin can be given as a single daily dose and relatively low doses can be clinically effective. Ear and kidney toxicity are minimized with lower doses. Gentamycin, like rifampin, is never given as solo therapy, it must be given in a cocktail with other drugs.
With these steps, I have successfully treated many cases.
I was asked recently by another physician what I do when patients don't get better.  My answer is go back to the drawing board, reconsider the diagnosis and options. Try a different approach. Sometimes you have to get creative. This is all unchartered water.
It may be necessary to juggle: IVig, hyperbaric oxygen therapy, IV gentamycin and other IV drugs while covering Lyme and sometimes Babesia species. 
A word about doxycycline.  A little bit of knowledge is dangerous and it is easy for a lay person to misinterpret things read on the internet.  Doxycycline does not kill only a small percent of Lyme bacteria and doxycycline is not a “cyst generator.” 
Doxycycline remains one of the very best drugs.  It is highly active against rapidly growing spirochete forms of Borrelia – perhaps the most active of any known drug.  It gets into tissues well when taken orally, including the brain. And, it may be given IV.  As is the case with two drugs mentioned above, rifampin and gentamycin, I don’t order doxycycline as solo therapy. It is part of a cocktail. If you look at Zhang’s work on in vitro eradication of Borrelia burdorferi, doxycycline is always a key component of successful three drug regimens. Doxycycline is also a primary component of many anti-Bartonella cocktails.
I have good success treating patients with therapies that are rational and can be explained within the context of available scientific facts.  My BLOGs and medical approaches to tick borne illness, are also based on empirical experience garnered over many years of trial and error practice.

A word about Bartonella testing. This patient tested positive for B. henselae.  Commercial antibody testing is unreliable. There are another 15 or so species and subspecies that may be clinically relevant for which no such test exists.  We got lucky here. I always tell patients: positive results are helpful, negative results are not. Clinical diagnosis is required in most cases.

The presence of darkly colored parallel stretch marks are hugely helpful, as in this case, but this is not a reliable sign.